Methodology & caveats
This report was compiled through targeted public-web research across trader-focused forums, podcast archives, publisher catalogues, regulator databases, and the traders' own primary channels. The candidate pool was widened to a working ~1,000 names surfaced from the US Investing Championship leaderboards, r/Daytrading and r/RealDayTrading flair posts, Chat With Traders' 320+ guest archive, SMB Capital's training desk profiles, Trillium alumni, Bookmap and Jigsaw Trading instructor rosters, TopstepTV regulars, Wyckoff Analytics, CMT Association speakers, Wiley / McGraw-Hill / Harriman House trading titles 2015–2026, the Market Wizards series, Barclay CTA rankings, SpotGamma and QVR media lists, and fintwit lists with the follower threshold lowered to 1k for niche specialists.
Every PnL figure in the Final 10 is either (a) sourced with a live URL, (b) paraphrased from a cited podcast or publication, or (c) clearly labelled Estimate with explicit reasoning — strategy type plus known or inferred account size plus typical realistic returns for that style and regime. Retail trading returns are inherently hard to verify. Brokerage statements are rarely published; tax-level verification exists for only a handful of names — Kullamägi's Swedish tax returns, Minervini's USIC audit, Hougaard's Danish competition media reporting, Brandt's Wiley-published self-disclosed VAMI.
The charlatan filter: for each finalist we ran "[name]" scam, "[name]" SEC, "[name]" FTC, and "[name]" lawsuit searches. Where noise surfaced the names were either downgraded to honorable mentions with caveats or excluded outright. Nobody on the Final 10 has a personal FTC, SEC, or FINRA enforcement action.
The search funnel
| Source bucket | Names surfaced | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| US Investing Championship 2019–2025 leaderboards | ~180 | Verified % returns |
| Chat With Traders episodes 001–322 | 322 | Day-trader style verification |
| r/RealDayTrading flaired traders | ~60 | Low-profile respected |
| SMB / Trillium / Kershner public alumni | ~80 | Prop-firm verified PnL |
| Topstep personalities + funded payouts | ~40 | Futures discretionary |
| Bookmap / Jigsaw / Axia Futures instructors | ~25 | Order-flow niche |
| Wyckoff Analytics / CMT speakers | ~50 | Method specialists |
| Harriman / Wiley / McGraw-Hill authors 2015–26 | ~90 | Vetted publishing |
| Barclay CTA & hedge-fund DB (small CTAs) | ~120 | Audited returns |
| SpotGamma / QVR / Eifert volatility circle | ~20 | Options-flow edge |
| Fintwit / StockTwits / X niche reach >1k | ~180 | Active retail / hybrid |
| Academic momentum-strategy authors (SSRN) | ~40 | Peer-reviewed edge |
| Podcasts: TradeCraft, Flirting with Models, Top Traders Unplugged, AlphaMind, The Derivative, Alpha Exchange | ~300 eps | Cross-referenced |
After deduplication and a first-pass filter — active within 18 months, no major charlatan flags, teachable method documented somewhere — the working shortlist was ~60 names, from which the Final Ten were selected on a combination of verifiability, methodological distinctiveness, and reader-usefulness. Read the ten →
Honorable mentions
Twelve traders who were close calls — strong resumes but displaced by a better-fitting finalist in their category, or niche enough that the Final 10 gets them implicit coverage. Each is worth following for the reason noted.
- Benn Eifert, QVR Advisors @bennpeifert
Co-CIO of QVR, former Wells Fargo prop trader, PhD UC Berkeley economics. Runs institutional volatility relative-value strategies (VIX futures dislocations, dispersion, Euro dividend futures). Regular on Mutiny Fund, Alpha Exchange, Bloomberg Odd Lots. Excluded from the Final 10 only because QVR funds are institutional-only — but for understanding the options-dealer ecosystem, essential reading.
- Mike Bellafiore, SMB Capital @MikeBellafiore
Co-founder of SMB Capital; author of One Good Trade and The PlayBook. Runs the NYC prop desk whose training program produces some of the strongest retail-to-prop transitions in the industry. Playbook-building framework is the best structured approach to self-development for discretionary traders. Dropped because his focus has shifted substantially to firm management and mentorship — Breitstein carries the SMB / Trillium / Kershner category.
- Brent Kochuba, SpotGamma
Founder of SpotGamma, coined the retail-accessible Gamma Exposure (GEX) framing in 2020. Former Credit Suisse / BofA derivatives broker. Daily levels (Zero Gamma, Call Wall, Put Wall, Volatility Trigger) are used widely by retail options traders. Karsan covers the same territory at a more institutional / strategic layer; SpotGamma is more of a data product — both valuable.
- Adam Grimes, MarketLife @AdamHGrimes
30+ year trader (NYMEX floor, hedge funds, prop), CMT, author of The Art and Science of Technical Analysis (Wiley). Runs MarketLife. His explicit framing that most price action is random and the task is finding the non-random windows is the most intellectually honest in retail education. Swapped for Karsan this iteration to add dealer-flow coverage.
- Anne-Marie Baiynd @AnneMarieTrades
Former neuroscience researcher; McGraw-Hill author (The Trading Book, 2011); Fibonacci / harmonic specialist; regular TopstepTV personality. Trades futures and equities on multiple timeframes. Method is more classical-TA than differentiated, but she remains a high-integrity voice.
- Pete Stolcers, OneOption @1OptionsTrading
30+ year career from CBOE floor to retail options desk to his own shop OneOption. Transparent, reasonably priced chatroom. Strong strategy stack (AVWAP, 200-day MA, volume confirmation on options flow). Mixed reviews online but no regulatory actions; Stock Gumshoe long-term reviewers lean positive.
- Tom Dante @Trader_Dante
London-based Bund (German 10Y) futures intraday trader. Ex-prop at a London futures firm. His 2015 Chat With Traders Ep. 039 remains one of the most highly-rated episodes in the series. Very low profile — exactly the kind of low-follower-count, high-respect trader the expanded criteria wanted. Excluded only because his output cadence has been modest recently.
- Peter Davies, Jigsaw Trading
Founder of Jigsaw Trading, one of the most respected DOM / order-flow platforms. His Futures.io "Introduction to Order Flow — The Mechanics of Price Movement" is one of the foundational reads for futures day-traders. Jigsaw's course is used by Axia Futures for intern training. Niche but elite.
- Roman Bogomazov, Wyckoff Analytics
Adjunct professor at Golden Gate University for 10+ years; principal instructor at wyckoffanalytics.com. Co-authored the StockCharts.com Wyckoff Method tutorial. For understanding accumulation / distribution / composite operator thinking at a rigorous level, Bogomazov is the source.
- Merritt Black, Apteros Trading / SMB Capital
Crude oil futures intraday trader using Market Profile and order flow. Trains new traders at SMB Capital. Runs Apteros Trading for futures-focused education. Excellent order-flow-first futures voice.
- Stefanie Kammerman, The Stock Whisperer
26+ year Schonfeld Securities alum ("Rookie of the Year" in her class); specializes in Dark Pool print analysis. Popular YouTube / Trustpilot-reviewed trading room (~$70/mo Java Pit). Caveat: has mixed online reviews including a Ripoff Report complaint; no FINRA action. Included with caution.
- Michael Patak, Topstep founder
Not a trader-to-follow-for-trades, but founder of Topstep whose public commentary on funded-trader performance (30,000+ traders funded, $50M+ cumulative payouts reported in Topstep's 2025 updates) is the closest thing to a structural data view on discretionary futures-trader distribution. Context voice rather than signal voice.
Charlatan archetypes we filtered against
Twelve patterns that served as disqualifying flags during the search. Matching two or more was typically enough to drop a candidate. No specific people named below — we excluded anyone with these patterns from the Final 10 rather than calling them out here.
- FTC-enforced earnings-claims sellers. The Warrior Trading FTC case (2022, $3M settlement, $2.9M+ consumer refunds) is canonical. Anyone with a personal FTC action is excluded.
- High-priced course-seller with no PnL disclosure. A $5k+ course / mastermind without independently verifiable personal returns is either downgraded with caveats or excluded.
- Lifestyle marketers. Rented jet photos, before-and-after account screenshots, countdown-timer upsells. Almost universally a red flag.
- Discord / Telegram signal ops with no audit. Paid signal services without a Myfxbook / kinfo / third-party tracking link.
- Penny-stock pump-and-dump history. Documented coordinated pumps on low-float names. Excluded.
- Perpetual permabears / permabulls. Retrospective claim-selectivity is distinct from real track record.
- "$1k into $X" with no broker statement. Without broker screenshots or tax evidence, category noise.
- Prop-firm affiliate farmers. Revenue dominated by referral fees to prop firms with high failure rates. Caveat required.
- Deleted-tweet pattern. Traders who routinely delete losing calls while amplifying winners were cross-checked via
[name] deleted tweetsearches. - Unregistered fund solicitation. SEC-enforcement risk even absent formal action.
- Ghost-written books. Several trading titles are packaged by publisher marketing with the "author" barely involved.
- Faux-institutional branding. "Hedge fund" that is a single-person LLC; "Managing Partner" of a firm with no AUM disclosure.
Sources consulted
Primary interviews, podcasts & channels
- Chat With Traders — full archive · Ep. 212 (Kullamägi), Ep. 229 (Breitstein Pt 2), Ep. 039 (Tom Dante), Ep. 255 & 312 (Bruzzese), Ep. 309 (Schwager), Ep. 308 (Dimitroff)
- TradeCraft with Vincent Bruzzese
- Mutiny Fund Podcast — Cem Karsan · Benn Eifert
- Adam Taggart / Thoughtful Money — Karsan series 2025
- Alpha Exchange with Dean Curnutt — Benn Eifert
- ReSolve Riffs — Karsan · Eifert & Maidel
- The Wall Street Coach · Ep. 56 — Breitstein
Official trader channels
- qullamaggie.com · theonelanceb.com · alphatrends.net · tradertom.com
- minervini.com · lindaraschke.net · peterlbrandt.com · traderfeed.blogspot.com
- Kai Wealth · trader-dante.com · wyckoffanalytics.com
- jigsawtrading.com · spotgamma.com · oneoption.com
Verification · competition · regulatory
- US Investing Championship — 2024 Final Results
- 2025 USIC First Half Results
- 2026 World Records — USIC / IIC
- financial-competitions.com
- FTC v. Warrior Trading (2022)
- FTC Warrior Trading refunds (2023)
- FINRA Disciplinary Actions Database
Community · forum references
- r/RealDayTrading · Damn Wiki
- r/Daytrading · r/Futures
- Elite Trader · Futures.io · StockTwits
- Bookmap blog — trader interviews
Academic · strategy research
- Zarattini, Aziz, Barbon — "A Profitable Day Trading Strategy" (SSRN)
- Zarattini, Aziz, Barbon — "Beat the Market — Intraday Momentum for SPY" (SSRN)